Defense lawyers want jurors to hear from a retired fire investigator, while prosecutors challenge the basis for his proposed testimony.
LOS ANGELES, Calif. — A new dispute over alleged firework evidence has emerged in the federal retrial of Jonathan Rinderknecht, the man accused of starting the small New Year’s Day brush fire that prosecutors say later developed into the deadly Palisades Fire. The defense wants to introduce testimony concerning marks documented at a Pacific Palisades property owned by former NBA star Chris Bosh.
Defense attorney Steve Haney is seeking to call retired California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection investigator Michael T. Cole, whose proposed testimony could support the defense argument that fireworks, rather than Rinderknecht, may have caused the initial Lachman Fire on Jan. 1, 2025. Prosecutors are challenging Cole’s qualifications and the foundation for his conclusions, setting up an evidentiary question that could affect what jurors hear as the retrial continues.
According to a defense filing described in news reports, Cole is expected to testify that he documented a mark and what he regarded as an associated burn and smoke trail in the driveway and rear patio area of a residence near the fire site. The defense filing says Cole believes the marks are physical evidence that a firework was launched. Reporting identified the residence as a home owned by Bosh. Bosh has not been accused of starting the fire or charged with wrongdoing.
The proposed testimony does not go as far as declaring what caused the Lachman Fire. Haney said in the filing that Cole would not offer an opinion on the fire’s origin or ultimate cause. Instead, the defense seeks to use the evidence alongside witness accounts of fireworks in the area around the time the brush fire began, offering jurors an alternative to the prosecution’s theory that Rinderknecht deliberately ignited vegetation.
Federal prosecutors have urged the court to exclude Cole’s proposed opinion. In a filing quoted by news organizations, prosecutors challenged his qualifications to determine whether marks shown in photographs came from a firework. They also said his opinion rests on six drone photographs depicting a brown mark on the driveway and was not supported by an up-close inspection or physical testing. The government also raised concerns about when the defense disclosed the proposed witness.
The disagreement reaches a central issue in the case: how the original Lachman Fire started. Prosecutors allege Rinderknecht maliciously started a fire near Pacific Palisades early on Jan. 1, 2025. Authorities have said the smaller fire continued to smolder before strong winds contributed to its reemergence on Jan. 7 as the Palisades Fire, which became one of the most destructive wildfires in Los Angeles history.
Rinderknecht has pleaded not guilty. His lawyers have argued that the government lacks direct physical proof that he ignited the brush and have pointed to evidence they say supports other possible ignition sources. During opening statements in the retrial, the defense also focused on an experiment involving a barbecue lighter and dry vegetation. Prosecutors, meanwhile, have cited evidence that includes cellphone location information and surveillance material as they seek to establish Rinderknecht’s movements around the time the initial fire began.
The current proceeding follows a first federal trial that ended without a verdict. Reuters reported that the jury in that trial was divided 10-2 in favor of acquittal before a mistrial was declared. Prosecutors later returned with a revised case. The Justice Department says Rinderknecht now faces one count of destruction of property by means of fire and one count of arson affecting property used in interstate commerce under a superseding indictment filed in August.
The consequences of the fire remain central to the prosecution. The Palisades Fire killed 12 people and destroyed thousands of homes and other structures as it swept through neighborhoods along the Los Angeles coast. The Justice Department has said the blaze displaced thousands of people and affected residents, businesses and public agencies.
The defense’s attempt to introduce Cole’s testimony does not establish that a firework caused the Lachman Fire, and the dispute over his proposed evidence remains subject to the judge’s rulings. The case is assigned to U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang in Los Angeles, and the Justice Department says witness testimony is scheduled to resume Nov. 16.
Author note: Last updated November 15, 2026.