Landlord Accused of Killing Disabled Tenant, Burying Him Under Porch

Investigators say an anonymous tip, conflicting accounts and evidence at an Albuquerque rental property shifted the case from disappearance to homicide.

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. — A months-long search for a missing Albuquerque tenant became a homicide case after investigators found his remains buried beneath a porch and charged his landlord with murder, according to police and court records.

Jonah Jeter, 33, is accused in the death of Robert Debeary, 52, who had been missing since August. Albuquerque police say Debeary was fatally shot Aug. 12 and later buried at the Alcazar Street Northeast property where he had been renting. Jeter faces an open count of murder, three counts of tampering with evidence and aggravated burglary. The accusations have not been proven in court.

Debeary’s family told authorities they had not heard from him since Aug. 11, an unusual break in contact that prompted relatives to begin looking for him. Court documents say family members reported him missing after several days and told investigators that he had been having problems with his landlord. Surveillance video later showed Debeary outside his residence on Aug. 12, one of the last known images of him before his disappearance.

As relatives searched the property, they encountered details that raised concerns. According to the criminal complaint, family members said Jeter gave differing explanations about Debeary’s housing status. At one point, Jeter allegedly said Debeary had been evicted because he was behind on rent. Police later said Jeter told investigators that no formal eviction process had begun. Authorities have not identified a confirmed motive for Debeary’s death.

Investigators also focused on Debeary’s belongings. Family members reported that items in his room appeared to have been moved, and detectives later found his possessions in the apartment but could not locate his bed. Court records say Jeter told police Debeary did not have a bed. Investigators also reported finding blood inside the residence and several phones submerged in water. Those discoveries became part of the broader investigation but had not, by themselves, established what happened to Debeary.

The case took another turn after an anonymous caller contacted authorities in September. According to the criminal complaint, the caller reported seeing Jeter working in the backyard around the time Debeary disappeared, including digging and placing objects in the ground. Homicide detectives eventually assumed responsibility for the investigation as concerns about foul play increased.

In October, investigators obtained search warrants involving Jeter and the rental property. Police said firearms were discovered during a search of Jeter’s vehicle, leading to a separate arrest before he was charged in Debeary’s death. Detectives continued examining the Alcazar Street property, including the yard and the area beneath a porch.

On Oct. 27, investigators returned with human-remains detection dogs. Police said the dogs alerted to an area beneath the porch where detectives noticed disturbed ground. After digging, investigators found human remains about two feet below the surface along with a mattress and bed frame. The Office of the Medical Investigator identified the remains as Debeary’s, and an autopsy determined that he had suffered a gunshot wound to the head.

Police announced the murder case against Jeter on Nov. 11. City homicide records listed his arrest as a newly solved 2026 case, while the criminal prosecution remains pending. Jeter remained in custody at the Metropolitan Detention Center as the case moved through New Mexico’s court system. Authorities have not publicly established a motive, and the charges remain allegations unless proven in court.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.