Resident’s Death Sparks Criminal Case and Nursing Home Scrutiny

Police allege staff delayed calling 911 after 93-year-old Margaret “Peggy” Healey was found outside the Windsor Locks facility.

HARTFORD, Conn. — A former nursing supervisor at a Windsor Locks nursing home faces criminally negligent homicide and evidence-tampering charges in the death of a 93-year-old resident who wandered outside the facility during freezing weather in February.

Papy Bibo, who was a nursing supervisor at Bickford Health Care Center, appeared in Hartford Superior Court on Nov. 12 as the criminal case continued. Margaret “Peggy” Healey died after leaving the facility on Feb. 8 and spending hours outside, according to police. Authorities allege that employees did not promptly call 911 after she was found. Bibo has been released on bond while the charges are pending.

Police said Healey was able to leave her room and get outside the nursing home without staff stopping her. Investigators have said she was missing for more than three hours before being located in the snow. The case has focused not only on how Healey left the building but also on what staff members did after realizing she was missing and after she was found.

Investigators allege that Bibo did not call 911 after Healey was located and that emergency help was delayed. Police also alleged that he warned employees that they could go to prison if authorities were contacted. Those claims are allegations in a pending criminal case, and the charges against Bibo have not been proven in court.

Bibo was arrested months after Healey’s death and charged with criminally negligent homicide and tampering with physical evidence. Police also charged another former employee, certified nursing assistant Uchenna Obi. Obi faces charges of first-degree reckless endangerment and tampering with physical evidence. Authorities have alleged that Obi failed to make required rounds and ensure residents were safely in their rooms.

The arrests followed a months-long investigation into the circumstances surrounding Healey’s death. Police said she was able to leave through a rear door. Investigators examined staff actions, facility security and the response after workers discovered that Healey was missing. The criminal cases place those allegations before the courts, where prosecutors must prove the charges against each defendant.

Bibo had previously appeared in court in August, when a judge addressed conditions of his release. Healey’s relatives attended that proceeding and said they intended to continue following the case. Bibo remained free on bond as the prosecution moved forward.

The former Bickford Health Care Center has since closed. Its closure came after Healey’s death and amid broader scrutiny of the facility, including questions about staffing, security and the employment history of workers responsible for vulnerable residents. About 40 residents had to move when the facility shut down in the spring.

The case has also drawn attention from Connecticut lawmakers, who have discussed changes involving nursing-home staffing, background checks and hiring requirements. Those policy questions are separate from the criminal proceedings against Bibo and Obi, which remain subject to the court process and the presumption of innocence.

No final disposition of Bibo’s charges was reported following his Nov. 12 appearance. The criminally negligent homicide and evidence-tampering allegations remain pending as the case proceeds in Hartford Superior Court.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 16, 2026.