Man’s Severed Head Found in Bag — Four Years Later, Family Arrested

DNA work led investigators from unidentified remains in Placer County to a Citrus Heights family and two arrests.

FORESTHILL, Calif. — A four-year effort to identify human remains found near Foresthill was broken open by forensic genetic genealogy, allowing investigators to name the victim, trace his family and eventually arrest his wife and daughter, according to the Placer County Sheriff’s Office.

The victim was identified as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., 73, of Citrus Heights. Authorities said his daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, was arrested Nov. 17 on suspicion of murder, while his wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, was arrested on suspicion of being an accessory. The arrests marked the latest stage in a case that spent years focused first on a basic question: Who was the man whose remains had been found?

The case began Sept. 28, 2022, when a person walking a dog discovered a severed human head inside a trash bag in the Todd Valley area near Foresthill. Investigators could not initially identify the man because of decomposition. They also found no missing-person report or known homicide case that provided an apparent match.

Investigators conducted an autopsy and sent the skull to forensic specialists at California State University, Chico. Experts developed a preliminary age and race profile and produced an artist’s rendering intended to help identify the victim. Detectives compared the available information with missing-person cases, but the effort did not establish his identity.

DNA from the remains was also entered into the Combined DNA Index System, or CODIS, which is used by law enforcement agencies to compare genetic profiles. That search did not produce a match. With no name attached to the remains, investigators continued pursuing other forensic options while the case remained unresolved.

The investigation changed direction in January 2024, when detectives sent DNA for forensic genetic genealogy testing at Othram Labs. Unlike a conventional database match, the process can help investigators identify possible relatives and build family connections from genetic information. The analysis produced potential distant relatives of the unidentified man, according to the sheriff’s office.

The FBI then assisted Placer County investigators in tracing the family tree suggested by the genetic results. Agents and detectives interviewed distant relatives and obtained DNA samples for comparison. The work eventually established the victim’s identity as Fitzmaurice, authorities said.

Once investigators had a name, the case shifted from identification to determining what had happened to him. Detectives learned Fitzmaurice had never been reported missing and had last been known to live in Citrus Heights with his wife and adult daughter. Authorities said the women continued to live at the family’s Lichen Drive residence.

Investigators now allege that Mary Fitzmaurice killed her father at the Citrus Heights home and that her mother helped dispose of his remains. Authorities have not publicly described the evidence supporting that allegation or released a cause of death. They also have not identified a motive. The rest of Fitzmaurice’s remains have not been found.

Detectives served a search warrant at the Lichen Drive residence on Nov. 17 with assistance from the FBI’s Evidence Response Team. Mary and Gwenn Fitzmaurice were arrested later that day. The Citrus Heights Police Department and Contra Costa County Crime Lab also assisted during the broader investigation, while the Placer County Cold Case Foundation helped fund DNA testing, authorities said.

Sheriff Wayne Woo said the investigation also found that Fitzmaurice’s relatives had been led to believe he remained alive and that Social Security and CalPERS pension benefits continued to be received. Prosecutors said they were examining whether the evidence supports additional allegations tied to those payments. No such additional charges had been announced when officials discussed the case Wednesday.

The investigation remains open as detectives seek additional evidence, including the location of Fitzmaurice’s remaining remains and answers about how and why he died. Prosecutors were also reviewing the case before making final filing decisions against the two women.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.