Relatives say the teenage brothers were exceptionally close, while prosecutors are pursuing a second-degree murder case against the surviving twin.
WASHINGTON — The family of twin brothers at the center of a fatal Northeast Washington shooting says the Oct. 25 tragedy was an accident, even as prosecutors pursue an adult murder charge against the surviving 16-year-old and a judge has ordered him held without bond.
Jabrell Young, 16, died after being shot inside the family’s home in the 200 block of 46th Street NE. His identical twin, Jamari Young, also 16, is charged as an adult with second-degree murder while armed. Police said Jamari turned himself in Nov. 18, ending a search that began after he left the home following the shooting.
Court records describe a morning argument between the brothers that began around their adjacent basement bedrooms. A parent told investigators that the twins were arguing about someone entering a bedroom and touching personal belongings. The parent went downstairs and found the brothers tussling, then tried to separate them with another person, according to the affidavit.
The gun discharged during that confrontation, the parent told investigators. The affidavit says Jamari immediately apologized and said he did not mean for the gun to go off. The parent later identified by local news organizations as the twins’ mother, Chantel Poe, told investigators she believed the shooting was accidental because of the close relationship between her sons.
Poe continued to make that argument after Jamari appeared in court Thursday. She said the brothers loved one another and objected to any portrayal of her surviving son as someone who had deliberately killed his twin. The family’s account, however, does not resolve the criminal case. Prosecutors have argued that the available evidence is sufficient to support a second-degree murder charge.
A judge agreed there was probable cause for the case to move forward and ordered Jamari held without bond. The judge indicated that the evidence did not necessarily show an intent to kill, according to reports from the hearing, but found the circumstances could support the charge at this stage of the proceeding. A probable-cause finding is not a determination of guilt.
Police officers responded to the home at about 8:36 a.m. Oct. 25 and found Jabrell unconscious and not breathing. Emergency personnel tried to save him, but he was pronounced dead at the scene. Police initially described the death as a domestic homicide and later sought Jamari in connection with the shooting.
The investigation has also raised questions about firearms recovered or documented around the home. Detectives found two .45-caliber shell casings and three cartridges during a search, according to the arrest affidavit. Police also recovered a loaded 9mm pistol from a blanket beneath a parked vehicle after an officer saw someone from the home move the blanket outside.
Authorities said the 9mm handgun had been linked to a separate shooting in Northwest Washington in July. Publicly available records reviewed in the case do not establish that the handgun was used to shoot Jabrell, and investigators have not publicly identified the weapon responsible for his death. The separate history of the recovered gun remains part of the investigative record rather than proof of Jamari’s guilt in his brother’s death.
For the Young family, the criminal proceedings now follow a loss they describe as an unintended tragedy between two brothers who were deeply connected. For prosecutors, the question before the court is whether Jamari’s conduct meets the legal standard for second-degree murder while armed. That dispute will continue through the court process, where the charge remains an allegation unless proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.