Blood evidence, surveillance video and digital records formed the backbone of the case that sent Tomasz Kosowski to death row.
CLEARWATER, Fla. — Steven Cozzi vanished from his Florida law office in March 2023 without his wallet, keys or cellphone, and investigators never recovered his body. More than three years later, the evidence surrounding that disappearance led a judge to convict plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski of murder and sentence him to death.
The unusual absence of a recovered body became one of the central issues in Kosowski’s trial. Prosecutors told Pinellas Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone that forensic evidence, surveillance recordings and a reconstruction of Kosowski’s movements established that Cozzi was killed on March 21, 2023. Kosowski, who represented himself and waived a jury, argued that the state had not proved either the timing or the circumstances of Cozzi’s death.
Cozzi, 41, was an attorney representing defendants in litigation brought by Kosowski involving a medical practice. Prosecutors said the dispute became intensely personal for Kosowski and that he planned the killing before going to the law office in Largo on the day Cozzi disappeared.
Investigators found Cozzi’s blood in a bathroom at the law office. Prosecutors said the forensic evidence showed that a violent event occurred there. They also presented surveillance footage that they said showed Kosowski arriving at the office with a boxed wagon and leaving hours later with a cart that appeared heavily loaded.
Authorities then reconstructed Kosowski’s travel using surveillance footage and cellphone information. Prosecutors said that after leaving the law office, Kosowski drove south and eventually disposed of Cozzi’s body in a trash container along his route. The waste was later taken to a landfill, where investigators faced large amounts of compacted material that made recovering the remains nearly impossible.
The prosecution also presented evidence found after Kosowski’s arrest and during searches connected to the investigation. Authorities said Cozzi’s blood or DNA was detected beyond the law office, including evidence associated with Kosowski. Court records and testimony were used with video and location data to build a timeline despite the lack of a body.
Kosowski attacked that timeline during his closing argument. He questioned whether Cozzi died on March 21 and cited credit card activity after the disappearance. He also disputed prosecutors’ description of how he could have moved Cozzi, who weighed about 190 pounds, in a wagon and loaded him into a pickup truck. Kosowski called no witnesses and did not testify.
Bulone found Kosowski guilty of first-degree murder on Sept. 23. In the penalty phase, the judge found that prosecutors proved the killing was committed for financial gain and was cold, calculated and premeditated. The judge did not find another proposed aggravating factor requiring proof that the killing was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, with the missing body limiting evidence about precisely how Cozzi died.
On Friday, Bulone concluded that the proven aggravating circumstances outweighed mitigating factors and imposed a death sentence. Court records also show that Kosowski unsuccessfully moved to disqualify Bulone shortly before the sentence was issued.
The unresolved location of Cozzi’s remains continues to distinguish the case even after the conviction and sentence. His family has said the inability to recover and bury him has compounded their loss. Kosowski is now set to enter the appeals process, with the public defender’s office appointed to represent him.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.